“We keep having the same argument about money.” It’s one of the most common things couples tell me, and with the cost of living on many people’s minds, it’s rarely far from the surface. What often surprises people is that these arguments are usually about more than the dollars. They’re about security, fairness, trust and what each of you learned about money growing up.
What the research says
Financial issues are widely described as one of the most common sources of conflict between partners. A study published in the Journal of Financial Therapy by Britt, Huston and Durband (2010) examined what predicts money arguments between spouses, using reports from wives. In that sample, around 40% of wives reported that their couple argued about money.
The most interesting finding for me is where the strongest signal came from. The authors concluded that “costly communication”, meaning how a couple argues in general, was the dominant predictor of money arguments. Having less wealth did predict money arguments, but only once general arguing was taken into account. In other words, in this study, how couples communicated mattered more than how much they had.
The same paper draws on earlier research suggesting that financial disagreements are linked to negative ways of resolving conflict and are more likely to stay unresolved, and that higher debt is linked with more stress and conflict between spouses.
A few cautions are worth stating. This study was cross-sectional, so it shows associations and can’t tell us what causes what. It relied on wives’ reports only, and it was published in 2010, before the current cost-of-living pressures. It also didn’t measure separation or divorce directly. Even so, it fits what many couples notice: the topic of money tends to bring out the way you already argue, and it can make that pattern worse.
Why money gets so heated
From a counselling perspective, a few things commonly sit underneath money arguments:
- Different money stories. One partner grew up with careful budgeting, the other with “enjoy it while you can”. Neither is wrong, but they can feel like a values clash.
- Fear and shame. Debt, job insecurity, or a spending mistake can bring up embarrassment, which often comes out as defensiveness or anger.
- What money represents. Security, freedom, control, being cared for. When those meanings aren’t spoken about, partners can end up arguing about the symbol and not the need.
- An existing pattern. If one of you tends to push for answers while the other pulls away, money will tend to trigger it. Our post on the demand-withdraw pattern explains this in more detail.
Ways to talk about money that tend to help
- Pick your moment. Raising the budget at 10 pm, or in the middle of an argument, rarely goes well. Agree on a calm time to talk, and keep it to a set length.
- Start with what you share. Begin with a goal you both care about, such as paying down a debt, a holiday, or feeling less anxious about bills, before getting into who spent what.
- Use “I” statements. “I feel anxious when I don’t know what’s in the account” lands very differently from “You’re always spending”. See our post on the power of “I” statements.
- Separate facts from feelings. Look at the numbers together first, then talk about what they mean for each of you.
- Agree some simple rules. For example, a dollar amount above which you check with each other first, or a small personal allowance each that needs no explanation.
- Take a break if it escalates. If either of you is overwhelmed, pause and come back to it. Our post on how to de-escalate a difficult situation has some ideas.
- Know what’s negotiable. Some money issues can be compromised on and some touch core values. Our post on negotiable and non-negotiable issues can help you sort them.
When money is being used to control
It’s important to say that not every money problem is a communication problem. If one partner controls all the finances, restricts your access to money, monitors every purchase, stops you working, or pressures you into debt, that may be financial abuse, which is recognised as a form of domestic and family violence. If that sounds familiar, please see our posts on coercive control and our free resource Are You Safe in Your Relationship?. 1800RESPECT is available 24 hours a day on 1800 737 732.
When to consider couples counselling
If you keep having the same money argument, if you avoid the topic altogether, or if it’s starting to affect how close you feel, a neutral third person can help. In couples counselling, we focus on how you talk about money and the pattern you fall into, not on telling you how to spend. That often makes the practical decisions a lot easier.
Sunny Coast Counselling offers couples counselling in person on the Sunshine Coast, and via Zoom and phone across Australia and New Zealand.
If you’d like to book a couples counselling session, click here.
Sources:
- Britt, S. L., Huston, S., & Durband, D. B. (2010). The determinants of money arguments between spouses. Journal of Financial Therapy, 1(1). https://ksu.janeway.systems/jft/article/5610/galley/5565/download
- 1800RESPECT. Financial abuse. https://1800respect.org.au/violence-and-abuse/financial-abuse
