Counselling is a privilege, and it is also a job in which you spend hours each week listening to other people’s distress. Most counsellors understand this in theory. It can be harder to recognise in practice, particularly when the effects build slowly and you are busy being the person others rely on.
If you have noticed that you are carrying clients’ stories home, dreading certain sessions, or feeling flatter than you used to, you are not failing at the work. These are recognised occupational risks, and supervision is one of the places where they can be talked about early.
A quick guide to the terms
The language in this area overlaps, and different researchers use the terms in slightly different ways. As a working guide:
- Burnout is exhaustion, cynicism and a reduced sense of effectiveness, usually linked to the demands of work overtime.
- Secondary traumatic stress involves symptoms similar to post-traumatic stress, such as intrusive images, avoidance or feeling on edge, arising from exposure to a client’s trauma.
- Vicarious trauma refers to changes in a helper’s own beliefs and sense of safety, trust or meaning after repeated exposure to clients’ traumatic material.
- Compassion fatigue is often used as an umbrella term covering burnout and secondary traumatic stress.
What the research says about what makes it worse, and better
A systematic review of 15 quantitative studies, covering 3,356 mental health professionals from 10 countries, looked at the work-related factors linked to compassion fatigue (Singh et al., 2020). Rather than focusing only on individual traits, it examined job demands and job resources.
On the demands side, workplace trauma, workload (including caseload size) and the therapeutic setting were most commonly linked to compassion fatigue.
On the resources side, the findings are worth noticing for anyone in private practice. Emotional support from colleagues was associated with lower burnout, and it was the only resource in the review linked with lower secondary traumatic stress as well. Support from a line manager and regular supervision were associated with lower burnout, and consulting a line manager was linked to lower secondary traumatic stress. Trust between supervisor and supervisee was also associated with lower burnout. Access to employee assistance services, relevant training and evidence-based practice appeared to help as well (Singh et al., 2020).
A caution about what this can and cannot tell us
All the studies in the review were cross-sectional, which means they show associations, not cause and effect. The quality of the studies varied: by the review’s own ratings, six were poor, five average and four good or very good. Most of the research is also from people employed in organisations, and private practice can look quite different (Singh et al., 2020).
The wider picture on supervision is similar. A review of 20 earlier reviews concluded that support for the benefits of supervision rests largely on indirect, correlational evidence, and that evidence for its effects on worker and client outcomes is weak (Watkins, 2020). That does not mean supervision isn’t useful. It means that we should be modest about our claims, and that how supervision is used matters.
Signs worth paying attention to
The following are practice observations rather than findings from the studies above:
- Dread or irritation before a particular clients’ sessions, or finding yourself avoiding certain topics.
- Intrusive thoughts or images about clients’ stories outside work.
- Feeling numb, cynical or less empathic than usual.
- Disrupted sleep, withdrawing from friends, or leaning more heavily on alcohol or other coping habits.
- Taking on more and more clients because it is hard to say no, especially when the diary is also your income.
How supervision can help
Good supervision gives you a regular, confidential place to say the things that are harder to say elsewhere, such as “that session is staying with me”. Beyond that, supervision can help you to:
- Notice patterns early, such as a gradual shift in your caseload towards heavy trauma work.
- Look at the structure of your practice (caseload mix, breaks between sessions, leave) as well as individual cases.
- Make a realistic self-care and support plan and check back on it.
- Separate what is yours from what belongs to the client, which links closely to countertransference.
Support between sessions matters too. Given the finding on colleague support, consider peer consultation, a small group of colleagues you trust, or your own counselling if the work is weighing on you.
If you are considering supervision, I offer individual and group clinical supervision in person on the Sunshine Coast and online. Please complete the form below if you’d like to know more about my supervision services.
References
Singh, J., Karanika-Murray, M., Baguley, T., & Hudson, J. (2020). A systematic review of job demands and resources associated with compassion fatigue in mental health professionals. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(19), 6987. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17196987
Watkins, C. E., Jr. (2020). What do clinical supervision research reviews tell us? Surveying the last 25 years. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research. https://doi.org/10.1002/capr.12287
This article is general information for counsellors and is not a substitute for your own supervision or professional support. If you are in distress, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 or, in an emergency, 000.
